Chii chokutanga akazviratidza huku kana zai? Dinosaur!

Kukurukurwa kutsanangura nguva dzose kukwezvwa vazivi. Mumwe wavo ari avanoziva kwatiri. Chii akauya wokutanga huku kana zai? Kudivi rimwe, mutsara kare vakauya kufananidzira chinhu nharo uye zvisarudzo zvisingagoni kuwanikwa. Ukuwo, pamusoro dambudziko kufunga vazivi vemazera ose, uye kunyange masayendisiti ano. Ndinofanira kutaura kuti wemanomano iri chaipo Pfungwa. Pakutanga, Zvaiita haana kuita "huku kana zai", asi se "zai kana shiri." Izvi zvinokosha nokuti anopa mukana generalize. Heino mimwe mienzaniso.

Chii chokutanga akazviratidza huku kana zai? pfungwa yekare

Aristotle uye Plutarch vakasvika pakugumisa kuti vakanga panguva imwe chete, vachitaura pamusoro nyaya. Chicken (kana yehuku) akaberekerwa kubva mazai, zvisinei harigoni wokutanga. Zai ane huku, saka paro harigoni kuva wokutanga. Somugumisiro, havana panguva imwe chete.

Chii kuoneka: zai kana huku (kubva nemaonero chenyanzvi ano)

Vomunguva zvakapfuura runonyengera; ivo kuongorora zvinoreva mashoko. Somuenzaniso, zai, vanoti - ndiwo nhevedzano kunotouraya zvakazoita kuti paumbwe chimiro chakadaro. Pasina mubvunzo, mhinduro yacho chete: zai rakasvika pakutanga nokuti zai anozvarwa asina chete shiri, asi dinosaurs uye dzimwe mhuka kuti akararama pamberi pavo.

Kana tine mupfungwa chete zai, mubvunzo unoramba seisingapindurwi: masayendisiti havambokwanisi chokwadi.

Pakupindura mubvunzo: "Chii kuoneka: huku kana zai" - shoko "huku" yokutsiva shoko "shiri", unofanira kutaura zvakasiyana. Chokwadi, pakanga kusvika huku nezvimwe mhando shiri. Vamwe vavo vaiva zvenguva, uye ane zvinhu haisiri akafanana huku. Vakanga vakatakura zvakafanana mazai. Uye chete panguva imwe chaiyo nguva vakadaidzwa nemashoko "huku" kana "Egg". Kwakadaro-yakareba nezvavanofunga uye regai kupindura mubvunzo uyu. nzira iyi kubvunza mibvunzo nemhinduro kushandisa pfungwa damerau vhoriyamu. Izvi zvinoreva kuti mumwe izwi dziri okuti, hakuna pachena chinangwa. Zvinoshanda zai? Ndiani chinorehwa nezita huku? Munhu wose anogona kupa mashoko avo, upamhi hwazvo kana rakatetepa zvaanoreva. mubvunzo Unparadoxical vanofanira kutaura kwete pamusoro zai uye zai huku. Ndokusaka pasina mhinduro, kana panzvimbo, pangava wandei.

1. Egg nekuti zai kwenheyo akazviratidza ipapa pane akaumba mumwe maonero inonzi "huku."
2. Chicken, nokuti waiva mazai nebere.

Other musoro kutsanangura

kutsanangura kwakadaro - a Workout kukuru mupfungwa. History anoziva zvakawanda kwavari.

1. Zvose zvakanyorwa pano - kwete kwechokwadi. Kana taifunga kuti kukosha kwechokwadi kuchinzi, zvichava venhema. Asi kana isu kusakoshesa kuti shoko iri yenhema, zvino chokwadi achanyorwa.
2. Woga pachako pazvose, kunyange panguva yakabuda mumugwagwa. (Petronius).
3. Kana bhokisi rima kuisa katsi, akaisa nyundo uye chinu chepfu, katsi mupenyu uye akafa panguva imwecheteyo (Schrödinger).
4. Kana nemurwi kuchenesa pamusoro tsanga jecha, kana wafa kuva boka?

gangaidzo kwakadaro kungava notional, attributive, probabilistic, akarongeka, topological etc.